Smallholder Irrigation for a Greener Africa

Smallholder farmers make up close to 70% of agricultural production in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). Most of the crops on these lands are rain-fed, hence their production is highly susceptible to variabilities in rainfall (Koigi, 2022). As such, there is a huge potential to boost agricultural productivity through irrigation. For instance, farmers who are able to produce during dry seasons tend to earn substantially more (Jayne et al. 2016).

Construction plans are already underway to build new and expand existing irrigation systems, such as the Shire Valley Transformation Programme in Malawi and the Bura and Mwea in Kenya (Merrey, 2020). These large-scale programmes are well-funded by institutions like the World Bank. However, is larger necessarily better?

The Office du Niger Tragedy

In 1932, the French colonisers established a canal irrigation system at the Niger River in Mali to scale up the cotton supply for their booming textile industry. Known as ‘Office du Niger’, it is one of the oldest and largest irrigation systems in the Sahel (figure 1). The scheme forced farmers to transition from cultivating diversified crops to monoculture (Staunton 2021). Very soon, however, the soil began to degrade, and farmers started suffering from malnutrition and loss of livelihoods (Bjornlund et al., 2020). Office du Niger is one of the major examples where the expansion and institutionalisation of irrigation leave drastic deterioration in local conditions.

Figure 1: Map of Office du Niger (Brondeau, 2018)

The donor curse and causes of failure

Donors and funding agencies are drawn to large-scale, profitable projects, as they are more rewarding and impressive than funding individual farmers, which is evident in multiple cases (e.g., Kikuchi et al., 2020; Staunton 2021).

Figure 2: correlation between project size, unit costs
and return on investment of irrigation projects in SSA (Fujiie et al., 2011)

Larger systems also tend to be output-oriented rather than risk-averse. Smallholder irrigation systems, on the other hand, are readily adapted to the local environments and can more quickly react to changes as they are not constrained by rigid irrigation or management systems (Bjornlund, Bjornlund and van Rooyen, 2020). Moreover, large-scale schemes require substantially higher upfront investment into systems considered ‘over-sophisticated’, that require continuous maintenance funding (Veldwisch et al., 2013) (figure 2). In addition, African countries - inherently diverse and with a postcolonial legacy - often lack strong central governments, political consensus and management capacities compared to countries like China, making it more challenging to sustain centralised schemes (Giordano et al., 2012; Kikuchi et al., 2020).

Small is beautiful

That small-scale irrigation succeeds over large-scale, centralised systems in SSA is, in fact, a prime example of Elinor Ostrom’s eminent idea on the collective management of common pool resources (Bjornlund et al., 2020). Here are some ways to promote small-holder irrigation: 

  • constructing storage infrastructure to ensure reliable water access;
  • investing in developing institutional capacity and promoting micro-scale irrigation technologies (Mati et al., 2008);
  • abolishing post-colonial legacy, and engaging smallholder farmers in the design and implementation processes of irrigation systems (Ostrom, 1992; Staunton 2021).

Comments

  1. Clement14 November 2022 at 22:51

    Your post demonstrates sound grasp of water and food issues in Africa, especailly challenges of irrigation, and these two post build on each other with relevant case study engaging with a mix of literarues. The referencing format need to improve.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Richard taylor6 December 2022 at 12:59

    Thanks for this well argued post that draws from an interesting and diverse literature. The presented referencing format is fine and clear - although Harvard-style referencing is not consistently used in blogs more generally, within the context of the UCL course, Water & Development in Africa, it is a reasonable and acceptable format to identify clearly all cited material. I am a little unclear about what "weakness of human nature" you refer - is it a tendency to be impressed by big things? If so, I am not certain how universal this weakness is. I, for one, am usually horrified by "big things".

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Groundwater - North Africa's Blue Gold 1

Image
At the recent 27th Conference of the Parties (COP27) under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), countries convened in pursuit of raising awareness and scaling up actions to address the climate emergency (UNFCCC, 2022) . Having had the chance to attend the conference in person, I am using this entry to reflect on my personal experiences and highlight issues within the North African agriculture sector. COP27 - new hopes for Water and Food? Being held in Egpyt, one of the aridest regions in Africa, climate adaptation naturally became a core topic at COP27. Water - a key aspect of adaptation - seemed to have benefited from this attention (GWP, 2019) . Although the topic is only briefly touched upon in the Koronivia Joint Programme (UNFCCC’s main programme on agriculture) water made it onto the final, overarching outcome, or formally, “ the Sharm el-Sheikh Implementation Plan ” as an independent agenda item. This is a major milestone from last year’s Glasgow Climate P...
Read more

The Sahelian Paradox in the Niger River Basin

Image
While North Africa faces the depletion of its non-renewable groundwater resources, the Sahel, on the contrary, struggles with too much renewable groundwater. The paradox in Niamey, Niger Niger, like many semi-arid countries of the Sahel, experiences constant variations in precipitation. From the 1970s to the late 20th century, rainfall significantly reduced, and droughts became longer. At the same time, quite paradoxically, a constant increase in groundwater level was recorded (Leblanc et al., 2008 ). This phenomenon called ‘the Sahelian paradox’ is typical for southwestern Niger, where regular droughts and rapid population growth have driven up the demand for agricultural production ( Favreau et al., 2009 ). Extensive areas of land were cleared in the 1950s, which has led to extensive and long-term losses of vegetation cover in the savannah. Cultivated land reduced the amount of evapotranspiration, and in turn, increased Hortonian runoff. As a consequence, the groundwater table cli...
Read more

The Essence of Food and Water in Africa

Image
My interest in water and food started when I was building a Global Youth Development Agenda on Water as a part of an initiative for the World Meteorological Organisation. While this experience increased my awareness of the complexity of water governance, I observed that food and water issues are often treated in isolation in governmental agendas, despite their inherent connection. Nearly 70% of the global freshwater is withdrawn for irrigation, and fertiliser runoff causes 78% of global freshwater eutrophication (Ritchie and Roser, 2020) .  COP27 will be hosted in Africa, a continent with the lowest per capita freshwater withdrawals and rates of food production ( Funk and Brown, 2009 ; Wada and Bierkens, 2014 ). As such, climate adaptation is at the centre of climate debates, where UN Sustainable Development Goals 2 and 6 - established to achieve ‘zero hunger’ and ‘clean water and sanitation for all' by 2030 respectively - are particularly prevalent. Hence, I wish to take a closer...
Read more